Cloud? Nein

Broadband connection lost

Before you reach the oldest village in Europe – at Skara Brae, in Orkney – you have to travel back in time. From the visitor centre, out across the tussocky grass, there’s a waymarked route, punctuated with milestones, taking you on a history lesson back to the beginnings of society. I imagine it’s to help build suspense across what is, actually, quite a bleak, wind-scorched promontery.

“1969, Man Lands on the Moon” declares the first painted boulder. Further along, “1492, Columbus reaches America”. You get the idea.

Back, back it goes. By the time you reach the 2,500 BCE marker post, “The Great Pyramid of Giza completed”, you can taste the sea spray on your lips. Skara Brae, hunkered into the coastline, lies just ahead, and even further back in time. It was built at least 700 years before the pyramids – at around 3,200 BCE.

Here, sunk into the subsoil, is a startlingly complete set of Neolithic houses, woven together in a series of paved passageways. If only the builders charged with the new Edge Lane development could take a field trip, we might be spared the heartache and court battles when residents are uprooted, as the new houses are demolished in twenty years’ time.

Skara Brae’s dwellings are no Neolithic student digs – these are fully furnished luxury seaside residences. Like a prototype Centre Parcs, the layout of each house is pretty standard. Hearth in the centre, seating around the walls and, pride of place,  the dresser – a huge stone cabinet constructed with one thing in mind. To display their nick-nacks.

Now, this was in a time before the Franklyn Mint, so instead of limited edition hand-painted John Wayne dinner plates, they’d no doubt have had to make do with sea shells, sheep skulls and early Echo and the Bunnymen cassettes.

The point? That, ever since we came down from the trees, we’ve been hoarders. We’ve defined ourselves by the stuff that surrounds us.
In fact, that’s probably why we stopped swinging from the canopies. It’s difficult to keep a grip of your Louis Vuitton when you’re grappling with a bonobo, 60 feet above the forest floor.

I guess the clue’s in the phrase ‘hunter gatherers’. Not content with merely stalking buffalo, we were desperate to collect a glittery pebble collection the envy of our neighbours.

So, the more I hear about the Cloud – the concept of actually owning nothing ‘real’, but uplinking to a Google land of plenty, somewhere over the rainbow, the more I feel we’re just not ready to let go of our wordly goods just yet.

David's dodgy dewey system

Millions of years of evolution and what will we have to show for it? An account with Audible.com and an iPad? We’re just not hardwired for that. What would happen to the Hello photospreads, if Stephanie Beacham couldn’t be photographed next to a mahogany bookcase groaning with a leather-bound collection of first editions?

Charlie Brooker’s a fan of ebooks.

He loves the fact you can buy books secretly, with no-one sensing your shame as you flick through the pages of a mid-period Dick Francis on the tube.

Maybe.

But a quick trawl though the last five paperbacks I’ve bought reveals a grim, but all too predictable, fact. Every single book was cheaper to buy in its paper and ink version than it is to purchase as an ebook.

How does that work? Sure, there’s a platform cost attached – to be gobbled up by Kindle (or whoever) but the maths just doesn’t stack up.

800 pages, a fancy cover jacket, distribution costs and retailer mark up, and still the ‘real’ book is cheaper than the virtual arrangement of dots on a screen. I smell profiteering, when I’d rather crack open a new hardback, and smell the 200gsm wood-free pulp, and arrange my collection on my dresser.

And when you’re done with your real book you’re free to lend it to your friends, give it to the charity shop, hollow it out to store narcotics. Whatever you like.

Your Kindle book? That’s locked down. For your eyes only. And, should Kindle fall from grace, you’re going to have to re-up your Dick Francis all over again, on the next shiny new paperless delivery method.

Books are more than mere vessels for stories. They’re as much a timeline though our lives as those clifftop markers in Orkney. Unlike music, which you plug in and play, while you go about your business with a fine Merlot and a lovely young lady from Match.com, you hold a book to you,  enjoy the ritual of the turned page and dog-eared progression through it, and no cloud can come close to that  experience.

Call me Neolithic.

6 thoughts on “Cloud? Nein

  1. The picture, I always thought it was Lloydy’s Lovely Library?

    And what are you doing with a copy of The Last Pope?

  2. Nice. A finely chosen book is the greatest gift you can give, too, in my humble one. I doubt a text file has the same romance and weight behind it.

    I did my A Level archaeology course work on Skara Brae. One day…

  3. I have been to Skara Brae, it rained, a lot.

    I recently persuaded the mum to buy an ebook reader, as she has bad arthritis and it gets tiring turning the pages after a while.

    It only arrived yesterday so haven’t had much chance to play with it yet, it can hold 1000′s of books, so can be taken into hospital with her etc.

    As for the cost of ebooks, you can find them on ebay and buy 100′s for a couple of £, not sure if that is legal or not?

    Anyhoo I agree that nothing beats a good book and I am not turning to an ebook reader anytime soon, as the only time I unplug from technology is usually to sleep or read.

    But there are some good uses for them.